The Mesquite Online News - Texas A&M University-San Antonio

Column: Good story takes backseat to ethics review

As of Nov. 19, approximately 63 percent of students have purchased parking permits. Some students without permits re-use old tickets on their windshield to ward off more tickets from UPD. Photo illustration by Megan Head

By Juan Garcia

As public editor, it is my job to criticize the student run paper any time it is being unfair. But it’s also my responsibility to tell reporters and readers when the campus’ only student-run media outlet has done a good job. Here’s one case where I think the staff put critical thinking and ethics ahead of deadlines.

This semester there was an outcry against students who don’t pay for parking permits.

As of Dec. 6, 2,550 student parking permits have been sold, according to the university police department. Compare that to the approximately 4,000 students enrolled at Texas A&M-San Antonio this semester and you’ll see that we have a large proportion of the student body that is parking illegally.

How are those students pulling it off when everyone else has had to pay the full $60 for the privilege to park?

Sergeant Robert Lopez said there is no excuse for not buying the parking permit. The fine for parking without a permit is $50, and the longer students wait to purchase their permits, the greater students risk individual fines adding up to hundreds of dollars.

“We would like it if all the students bought the pass,” Lopez said. “But there is no set quota for how many get sold.”

Several complaints regarding the passes were brought to the attention of The Mesquite. During “Story Booth,” a Mesquite-sponsored outreach event in the cafeteria of Main Campus Building, one education major told a reporter that she avoids UPD by placing an old ticket on her windshield to avoid getting ticketed again.

Overhearing this, another student who paid for the permit, said students like that make her “incredibly mad.” She cautioned the newspaper that if they were going to report on parking issues, they better bring up the issue of cheating; students who claim excuses (not enough money, a household to run, limited hours on campus) are cheating those who pay for their permits.

The student run newspaper decided that it was their job to investigate the matter once it became apparent that permit holders were getting argumentative with non-permit holders who were finding illegal means to park.

However, before reporting on the issue, The Mesquite’s faculty adviser asked editors if they were in good standing with UPD. Did their own staff members all own parking permits?

Not exactly. Half of the editorial board members did not.

It is The Mesquite’s job to speak out on student issues; to be their voice when they feel as if their concerns are falling on deaf ears. However, at the same time they asked themselves whether it’s ethical to report on an issue where they are also having compliance issues.

Can a news staff objectively report on parking violations if its own members practice the same tricks? One admitted that she places an old ticket on her dashboard to ward off UPD. As an editor on assignment, and parking illegally, she had to ask whether student reporters should be held to higher standards.

You’ll notice that The Mesquite hasn’t written about parking permits this semester, even though it’s been a concern among students. The student-run newspaper believes in fair and accurate reporting.

Although they devote themselves to working tirelessly for the student body, they must always be aware of how they are representing themselves. In this instance, they put their ethics ahead of a good story and the whole university needs to be mindful of this.

Hopefully, in the spring The Mesquite will be able to follow parking trends and pick up where this semester’s staff left off. But only if everyone on the news team purchases their parking permits, which is now part of student media policy.

About the Author

Juan Garcia
Juan Garcia
Juan Garcia is the Public Editor for The Mesquite. Previously, he reported on the growth and development of the University’s Student Government Association. A communication-journalism major with a minor in English, Juan is employed part-time as a student assistant to the Director of Campus Safety and Security at A&M-San Antonio. He is a 2001 Lytle High School graduate and attended Palo Alto College where he received associate’s degrees in English and liberal studies in 2007. Juan is the father of a 3-year-old daughter

Join the Conversation

© 2019 Jaguar Student Media | Texas A&M University-San Antonio. All Rights Reserved. All Rights Reserved.
San Antonio Website Design & Development - Backyard Studios
Join Our Newsletter

Get the Mesquite News delivered straight to you.